WHEN A HIRING OR TEAM DECISION FEELS DIFFICULT

It’s understandable, you are affecting peoples lives but… it’s a thing you must get right for success. Hiring and firing is a crucial task for a business owner so everyone can thrive and even though it may seem like it, it’s not personal.

Develop your hiring skills and notice concerns early. Be clear about what the role needs, what you have observed and what support or change may help before deciding the person is not a fit.

Preparing notes for a workplace conversation

WHEN A WORKING RELATIONSHIP IS NOT GOING WELL

Unresolved concerns can affect more than the task itself. Depending on what is happening, you may notice:

Agreed procedures being missed.

Work needing repeated correction.

Customers not receiving the care they were promised.

Other team members having to pick up unfinished work.

Less willingness to rely on an agreement.

Time and products being used to put things right.

People raising concerns about how they are being treated.

Extra pressure on the team and the business.

These situations can affect the whole team and need attention. Start with the behaviour or work that is causing concern, rather than labelling the person.

Read our blog about hiring and onboarding new team members here.

Defining your culture and values plus having a vision will assist you in the hiring phase. Read our salon vision blog here.

WHICH PART OF THE WORKING RELATIONSHIP NEEDS ATTENTION?

Whether a new hire is not working out or a longstanding team member has shifted in performance you need to deal with this head-on.

If encouragement has not helped, ask what has been understood, what has been practised and what is still getting in the way. A lack of improvement does not, on its own, tell you what someone wants.

I use three questions to explore whether the work, role or working relationship fits. They help start a conversation; they do not decide an employment outcome.

  • Are they in the wrong seat on the bus?
  • Are they on the wrong bus?
  • Are they even in the right vehicle?

Let’s unpack this a little

WRONG SEAT.

Not everyone wants to be a balayage queen, stock controller, team trainer or men’s cutter.

Have you given opportunities to your team because you need help with tasks but they just aren’t suited to them?

They might never be a great trainer of the juniors but are excellent at growing and developing a loyal client base. They might love the admin roles but hate doing colour.

It’s up to you to make sure all your team have opportunities to grow in their own lane and reach heights in areas designed to suit them and which suits your business model. As the leader, it’s your job to identify their strengths and develop their talents.

But initially, the wrong seat on the bus can cause a lot of distress and disharmony. Work with this team member to get them in the right seat. If the role they want is not available, be honest about what the business can offer. Any change to their role needs to be discussed and handled through the appropriate employment process.

WRONG BUS.

Your salon and business framework will not suit everyone.

The procedures are too strict or casual. Your leadership style too loose or controlling. The products not green enough or the backroom too formal.

Sharing values and defining a culture that represents your individual salon is important so you get the right people on the bus. We talk about this important hiring detail here.

Interviewing well will hopefully avoid taking someone on who does not share your culture. Work through an exercise on creating a salon vision here.

WRONG VEHICLE.

The person may be unsure whether the work or industry is right for them. Give them room to explain what they want and what they are finding difficult.

Before treating this as a lack of motivation, consider the expectations, training and support they have had. A concern about the work deserves a fair conversation, not a decision about someone’s whole career made on their behalf.

YOU CAN’T WANT IT FOR THEM MORE THAN THEY WANT IT FOR THEMSELVES.

This is one of the best things I learnt after trying to teach a longstanding team member to be more ambitious and try to motivate them. However, it was to the detriment of my business and myself.

Use that lesson to check whether the goal is genuinely shared. You may want someone to become a trainer while they want to focus on their own customers. Understanding the difference helps you discuss what the role needs and what is actually available.

Who wants this… me or them?

A team joining hands

DEAL WITH THE CONCERN CLEARLY AND FAIRLY

It is understandable to want a difficult situation resolved quickly. Explain the actual concern, hear the employee’s view and agree the relevant support and next steps.

Changing someone’s role or ending employment needs the proper process for the country where your salon operates. The questions in this article help you understand the situation; they are not dismissal steps.

PERFORMANCE REVIEW INDICATORS.

Set targets and performance goals in a variety of areas so you have measurable, documented evidence to illustrate your concerns.

Set clear time frames and use relevant records, feedback and figures. Check that the information is accurate and comparable, then discuss what it shows and what it does not.

Grade the key performance areas that you rate within your business. Give them a rating and written feedback plus a goal to move towards for the next meeting. Agree a review frequency that fits the concern and gives a reasonable chance to practise and improve.

In my salon, we have goals for the first 3 months of a new trainees employment that are measured differently from a senior being employed with a clientele. Established seniors have varying targets and performance indicators depending on their status. They are all individual and break away from the ‘all suits all’ mentality. When it comes to needing to monitor performance it is very easy to then identify areas of consistently poor performance.

A clear record gives you something to discuss together. If progress is not happening, ask what the employee has understood and tried, what support was provided and what remains unresolved. Do not assume the same figures mean the same thing to both of you.

Areas where their work is strong can help you explore whether another available role would fit. They do not establish the cause of the difficulty on their own. Work this through together.

TEAM GOAL SETTING ANALYSIS.

I start each new team member with the task of goal setting. Helping them break down priorities over a time frame and how they are going to achieve these goals.

Have a list of questions that they answer for you about their goals. What they want to achieve, where they see themselves and how you can help get them there. Dig deeper than just target based achievements. Who do they want to become within your business, what are their big bold dreams?

If a goal is not being reached, look at what happened and what needs attention. An agreed goal gives you a starting point for discussion, rather than proof of the cause.

SALON VALUES AND CULTURE ALIGNMENT.

This is a first stage interview task but if you have not started here introduce it as soon as possible.

Get them to write down their personal and work values and what behaviours they will need to demonstrate to show these values.

Are they aligned with your business?

Are they currently behaving in a way that demonstrates these values within your culture?

For example, if respectful communication is part of your salon values, describe the behaviour that concerns you and ask about it. A disagreement or concern raised by a team member is not automatically disloyalty.

Bring the discussion back to the actual work, agreed expectations and how people treat each other. Keep the criteria relevant to the role and hear the other person’s view before deciding what to do.

Two people discussing work together

GIVE THE DECISION A CLEAR AND FAIR BASIS

That does not mean that you will never make mistakes… it’s part of the course for every business owner to learn through these situations. Stop, regroup and move through it. Lean into it and let it make you stronger.

Getting the right team, aligned with a culture that helps everyone thrive is the key to a happy team and invested customers.

YOUR SALON LEADERSHIP LIBRARY

If you are preparing to interview, the Interview Questions guide offers prompts for exploring how someone has worked and what the role needs. The Everyday Leadership guide can help you reflect on your approach to a difficult team situation. Both are in the Leadership Library.

GET THE FREE GUIDES